So Long J Dilla, and Thanks . . . (r.i.p. Jay Dee)

It's a very sad day. I just found out this afternoon that Jay Dee (James Yancey), aka J Dilla passed away yesterday. He was only 32. J Dilla had health problems in the past and reportedly died from kidney failure related to lupus nephritis.
Jay Dee produced or had a hand in defining the sound of so many great hip hops albums, including Tribe Called Quest's swan song The Love Movement, and some tracks from the Pharcyde's Labcabincalifornia, De La Soul's Stakes is High, and Erykah Badu's Mama's Gun. But his reknown as a skilled beat maker and demand as a producer really took off after he played a huge role in crafting the sound of Q Tip's Amplified in 1999 and Common's Like Water for Chocolate in 2000.
Along with rappers T3 and Baatin, Jay Dee formed the group Slum Village in the mid 1990's, putting out the underground classic Fantastic, Vol. 1 in 1996 (which was officially released in 2005) and Fantastic, Vol. 2 in 2000. The following year, Jay Dee released his first solo joint, Welcome 2 Detroit, on UK indie label bbe. Detroit featured guest spots from underground Motor City rappers. Last year J Dilla released an instrumental version of Welcome 2 Detroit -- damn, what a treat (see below). Jay Dee also teamed up with fellow producer, MC, crate digger, and jazz head Madlib to form Jlib, releasing Champion Sound in 2003.Here's some of what J Dilla said, on the bbe website, about buying 7" vinyl singles as a kid and how he then began snapping up jazz and soul albums:
The first record I remember buying was "Open Sesame" by Kool And The Gang on 7". I used to go to the record stores like every week and buy whatever was new on 7". I was so spoilt 'cos I had all the records. Then I got into Jack McDuff. I used to got to sleep listening to that shit, that's where the jazz influence came from. Album wise I started buying jazz first – then a lot of soul.
from Q Tip's Amplified:
and from Common's Like Water for Chocolate:
And just three days before his death, Dilla's latest project, Donuts dropped. A review copy of Donuts may be on its way to me (Hannah?). If not I'll pick it up soon and post a review and Jay Dee tribute, part II. From the initial reviews, Donuts should be phenomenal. Here's what the Stones Throw site says about the album:
Begun simply enough as a production beat tape, "Donuts" evolved into a project as unusual as the environment in which it was created. It's a hip-hop album without MC's. An album of electronic music that at times sounds like a 70s soul mixtape. Its abrupt transitions and numerous interludes might make you think you're rapidly turning the radio dial in some strange city where every station is programmed by a certain Detroit hip-hop producer. "Donuts" is J Dilla doing what he does best – crafting hip-hop, soul and electronic music into his own sound.
see also: Stones Throw myspace page Jay Dee's myspace page
J Dilla will be missed. To say the least. Review of Donuts to follow.
Peace.
UPDATE: as relax star vibe school and free hip hop now have noted, there will be a Dilla tribute spin on Tues. night @ the M Bar in NYC. Also, Del over @ vibes & stuff has a link to a Jay Dee tribute mix stream by DJ Venom (thanks Del). Kevin over @ So Much Silence has a great Dilla post featuring "Stakes is High" & Pharcyde cuts (!) and Straight Bangin' posted a particulary stellar Jay Dee tribute. Finally, look for o-dub's obit in LA Weekly and soul sides.
update UPDATE: Rafi Kam over @ oh word put together a fantastic piece that culls excepts from the best Dilla tributes and links to others (including los amigos), focusing in particular on the Jay Dee tracks & favorites lists folks posted-up. As Rafi notes, we all "came together to mourn [Dilla's loss] like a family":
There appeared hundreds of blog posts and thousands upon thousands of posts at message boards, myspace, etc. . . . [and] This was all within the first few days, all before Yahoo had given a news headline to Dilla on their front page. So many people had taken the initiative to share their memories of the man and ten plus years of great music.. . .
Labels: Hip Hop, J Dilla, Q Tip, Slum Village, Stones Throw Records


























9 Comments:
Oh please...
It's sad news that he's passed but let's be serious for a moment, a lot of his music was boring.
'The Love Movement' sucks majorly (and hopefully no revisionalism is going to take place now Jay Dilla is dead which makes everyone think it's a masterpiece comparable to their first 3 albums), 'Beats, Rhymes & Life' which he also contributed to wasn't as good as Tribes first 3 either.
Tip's solo sucks bar a couple of tracks.
'Like Water For Chocolate' has more of the Roots influence to it than Dilla's, same with Erykah Badu's album.
Every Slum Village release to date has been boring.
Jaylib was decent but Madlib was involved so...
Jay Dee was an average producer, he did some decent stuff, like Stakes Is High, and the Pharcyde tracks but on the whole he just wasn't all that, him (sadly) passing away doesn't change that nor should it.
It's like Pac became the greatest MC of all time after he died, when he wasn't anywhere close to claiming that crown.
yo wasteland D --
agreed that Tribe's Love Movement isn't in the same league (to say the least) w/ the first 3 albums (although saying it "sucks majorly" is overstating it a bit). I love Tip's Amplified, even though, hell yeah, it's also not up to early Tribe status.
moreover, you are right that there is a natural tendency to over hype and overstate the importance of an artist's work when they pass, especially when it's someone struck down in their prime.
note that my post never heralded Dilla as "one of the greatest of all time," or anything even close to that -- as many around the blogosphere have, as you point out in your post.
that said, a lot of us loved his work and believed that he was a very important force in progressive hip hop. On that point, your comrade Kwaj's post back in early December doesn't necessarily disagree.
p.s. we were in agreement, hip hop wise, for top 5 albums of 2005.
Agree with Matt here ... I didn't sense an overload of praise in the post, but more a respect for what the man did. That's usually what happens when people pass. It's OK to respect someone's work, even if you don't like it.
Yes, people tend to romanticize artist contributions after death. But what I think is important here is making others aware of Jay Dee's contributions to hip-hop.
thanks Kevin. very well said. "what I think is important here is making others aware of Jay Dee's contributions to hip-hop." damn straight.
The comment wasn't intended as an attack on you, it was the result of reading a thousand other posts about how one of the greats had died.
I've not read the post by Kwaj as he tends to talk nonsense so I don't bother reading. It's easier that way.
I personally don't feel that any criticism of 'The Love Movement' can really be too harsh. We're talking about one of my favourite groups of all time and they fell off on that album.
If that was someone's first experience of Tribe then I don't know how they could bring themselves to listen to their earlier work. Yes I find it that bad.
It wasn't just the influence of Jay Dee that made it a pian to listen to. There are many reasons which are well documented, such as the group imploding and the direction group members wanted to go with the music which just didn't pay off on that album. Jay Dee's influence however is a part of the reason, as I find a lot of his other work similar.
Tip's album just isn't good. There's a few track which are listenable but that's just not the Tip I was expecting. (And yes I fully accept my preconceptions about Tip and expectations for a 'classic' album do cloud my judgement about 'Amplified'.)
Dilla had some influence but I don't think it's as significant or as positive as a lot of people seem to be making out. That of course is personal opinion BUT it's not changed since his death, whereas others seem to be changing their opinion purely because he's dead.
The same thing happend with Pac and Biggie and look at the results... Honestly I've heard too many wack Pac verses and recycled Biggie tracks to have to put up with all the shelved tracks by Jay Dee as well!
So yeah... Sad that he died and he did make some good music but let's not go over the top, he wasn't that good or that positively significant to Hip Hop.
wasteland D --
hey man, you read o-dub's tribute post yesterday? He even posted up "Busta's Lament" from The Love Movement(!) I'm not gonna defend that album, and i hope anyone who made that their first taste of Tribe would seek out The Low End Theory and Midnight to find out why they really were one of the very best ever (those 2 albums gotta be in my top 20, if not top 10, of all time).
Thanks for the comments -- much appreciated even though we largely disagree. Hell i'd be at the Dilla tribute spin @ the M Bar tonight if i was down in NYC.
laters -- peace.
(side note to David -- maybe you should drop by the M Bar after your valentine's dinner w/ J -- hell maybe she'd even be willing to pop by)
O-Dub's post is exactly what I'm talking about... 'I didn't like him much but now he's dead, wow he was great'.
At least he didn't hide his hypocracy though like others.
Altrap is the only place I've seen a similar opinion to mine expressed...
ok. you get the last word on this. word. er, oh shit. sorry
I listened to Workinonit off of Donuts. I had no idea that he was using a 10CC song (Worst Band in the World from Sheet Music) as raw material
Post a Comment
<< Home